wordlist oddness?

[David Relson]

Clint,

I ran my test and didn't see anything wrong.  Below's what I did, with the 
outputs.  If you can reproduce your problem, pack the test message and the 
run outputs in a .tgz and send the file to me.

David

### first break the message into words, sort them, remove dups, and save

[relson at osage bogofilter-0.8.0]$ bogolexer -p < msg.1103.txt | sort -u > words

### get start-of-test counts for the first 10 words from the message

[relson at osage bogofilter-0.8.0]$ head words | bogoutil -w /var/lib/bogofilter
                        spam   good
64.83.123.32              0      0
about                   387   8350
adl                       0      1
advice                   36    642
advised                   2     55
after                   222   3853
ages                     17     47
all                     629   4309
already                  92   2188
amazing                 108    149

### update spam list from the message

[relson at osage bogofilter-0.8.0]$ bogofilter -s < msg.1103.txt

### then check counts for the first 10 words from the message
### notice that the counts went up.  Since bogofilter defaults to
### Graham it's okay for a count to increase as much as 4.

[relson at osage bogofilter-0.8.0]$ head words | bogoutil -w /var/lib/bogofilter
                        spam   good
64.83.123.32              1      0
about                   388   8350
adl                       1      1
advice                   39    642
advised                   3     55
after                   223   3853
ages                     18     47
all                     630   4309
already                  93   2188
amazing                 110    149

### repeat the update using '-r' (robinson) option.
### ... the counts went up by exactly one per word
### (consistent with max allowed by Robinson)

[relson at osage bogofilter-0.8.0]$ bogofilter -r -s < msg.1103.txt
[relson at osage bogofilter-0.8.0]$ head words | bogoutil -w /var/lib/bogofilter
                        spam   good
64.83.123.32              2      0
about                   389   8350
adl                       2      1
advice                   40    642
advised                   4     55
after                   224   3853
ages                     19     47
all                     631   4309
already                  94   2188
amazing                 111    149